ING Monthly: We’re in a polycrisis – and this is what it means
Things are brewing in the States There appears to be no respite from seemingly never-ending economic crises and concern. The banking crisis in the US is far from over, and even if regulators have been very efficient in ringfencing failing institutions up to now, we all know the adage that 'past performance is no guarantee of future success', and it's rarely been so true for financial markets right now. Tighter lending standards as a result of the recent banking turmoil will leave further marks on the real economy, with commercial real estate often cited as the possible next shoe to drop.
And there's more; the political debate on the debt ceiling is fiercer than ever, increasing the risk of an – intended or unintended – fatal accident: a default on US treasuries. A recent study by the US Council of Economic Advisors shows that a short default on US treasuries would cost 0.6 percentage points of GDP growth, while a protracted period would cost more than six percentage points. Leaving aside the effects of financial turmoil from such an unprecedented event, we still believe in a last-minute compromise. But the uncertainty and expenditure cuts in such a settlement will weigh on growth in the coming months. Add to this the ongoing student loan discussion and the lagged impact of the Fed’s tightening, and the US has its very own definition of polycrisis.
With a looming recession in the US, it is easy to see the Fed not only stopping rate hikes but also cutting rates at the end of the year. The situation in Europe, unfortunately, is slightly different. Here, the polycrisis of last year, the enormous structural challenges and transitions have somehow let a typical textbook business cycle disappear. Instead, the eurozone economy is facing a future of subdued growth at best. In fact, private consumption is still below pre-pandemic levels in real terms and industrial production is not really gaining momentum. Still, the European Central Bank has sent clear signals that it intends to continue hiking rates over the coming months. The question is whether these intentions can actually come true.
It is hard to see how the eurozone and the ECB can escape a recession and rate cuts in the US. What a luxury were those days with only a few crises! The macro policy answer was so much easier, but even then often disputed. Right now, we definitely don’t envy central bankers and governments. Finding the right answers is, to say the least, somewhat complicated.